HomeVichaar Vichaar

धोनी को धमकाना उचित नहीं

अति क्रिकेट को लेकर एक बार फिर मामला गरमाने लगा है। इस बार एशिया कप के कार्यक्रम को लेकर टीम इंडिया के कप्तान महेंद्र सिंह धोनी ने आवाज उठाई है। उन्होंने साफ-साफ कहा कि लगातार दो दिन में दो मैच खेलने से खेल प्रभावित हो रहा है।

भारत को लीग मैच में हांगकांग के साथ खेलने के अगले दिन पाकिस्तान से खेलना पड़ा था। अब सुपर-4 में 2 जुलाई को पाकिस्तान व 3 जुलाई को श्रीलंका के खिलाफ उसे खेलना है। धोनी के इस तर्क का टेस्ट कप्तान अनिल कुंबले ने भी समर्थन किया है। इस मामले में खिलाड़ियों का एक मत होना स्वाभाविक ही है।

धोनी ने तो सिर्फ एशिया कप को लेकर टिप्पणी की है लेकिन यह सचाई है कि क्रिकेटरों का अंतरराष्ट्रीय कार्यक्रम इतना अधिक व्यस्त हो गया है कि इंग्लैंड के केविन पीटरसन ने तो समय से पहले कैरियर खत्म होने की आशंका व्यक्त की है। पीटरसन से पहले स्टीव वॉ, रिकी पोंटिंग, सचिन तेंडुलकर व राहुल द्रविड़ भी अति क्रिकेट का विरोध कर चुके हैं।

ऐसे में धोनी ने अगर विरोध जताया है तो इसमें बीसीसीआई की ओर से उग्र प्रतिक्रिया समझ से परे है। बीसीसीआई के उपाध्यक्ष राजीव शुक्ला ने सीधे ही कह दिया कि आराम करना हो तो करें सभी खिलाड़ियों के विकल्प मौजूद हैं।

शुक्ला शायद यह नहीं जानते कि सचिन का कोई विकल्प नहीं हो सकता उसी प्रकार धोनी, युवराज सिंह, वीरेंद्र सहवाग, गौतम गंभीर के बिना कोई मैच जीतना कितना मुश्किल है। शुक्ला के धमकीनुमा बयान की इसलिए कोई अहमियत नहीं है क्योंकि यह बयान बीसीसीआई सचिव निरंजन शाह या अध्यक्ष शरद पवार की ओर से नहीं आया है। क्या वे यह नहीं जानते कि खिलाड़ियों को नाराज कर कोई जंग नहीं जीती जा सकती है। खिलाड़ी कोई बंदर तो है नहीं कि डुगडुगी बजाई और वे नाचना शुरु कर दें।

ज्यादा क्रिकेट से फिटनेस प्रभावित होने की सबसे अधिक चिंता होती है। अति क्रिकेट ने कई खिलाड़ियों के पारिवारिक जीवन को भी प्रभावित किया है। राष्ट्र की ओर से खेलना हर कोई अपनी शान समझता है। हर खिलाड़ी की कोशिश 100 प्रतिशत देने की होती है लेकिन बीसीसीआई यदि खिलाड़ी के दर्द को नहीं समझेगी तो कौन समझेगा।

इस साल टेस्ट, वनडे व आईपीएल सहित अभी तक धोनी ब्रिग्रेड 35 से ज्यादा मैच खेल चुकी है। आने वाले महीनों में लगभग इतने ही वनडे व टेस्ट खेलने हैं। ऐसे में अति क्रिकेट का विरोध यदि कोई खिलाड़ी करे तो उसे धमकाना अतार्किक व्यवहार ही माना जाना चाहिए।

अति क्रिकेट के इस विवाद में सहीं कौन है कप्तान धोनी या फिर बीसीसीआई? क्या अपने ही कप्तान को बीसीसीआई को इस तरह धमकाना उचित है?अपने विचार लिख भेजें।





अपने विचार यहां लिखें
नाम:
ईमेल आईडी:
भाषा चुनॆ
हिन्दी रॊमन‌ हिन्दी फॊनॆटिक English
विचार:
कोड:
 

आपके विचार
Vikas
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 1:19
Yes, its right. If any player feel tired , he can leave. Its opportunity for new players also
vikas
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 2:54
match apni jagah chal raha hai tu chalne de. agar kisi player ko problem hai tu wah bahar baitkar aaram kare. isse aur aache aur naye player khelenge. good for indian cricket. isse cricket ek professional ban jayega aur adhik se adhik log cricket khelenge agar BCCI yehi chahati hai tu.
romey
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 3:46
dhoni ko khud bhi aram karna chahiye...sehwag or yuvraj ko bahar nahi karna chahiye...jis great ganguly k karn dhoni team main aaya usi ko he bhul gya.....theek hai par banda badhiya nahi hai ye....
Manish
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 3:50
I fully agree with Rajeev Shukla. When playing for money in IPL Dhoni did not care about over playing? When acting on stage or modeling he did not care too. Then why now so much hue and cry? I think if Dhoni wants rest he should take it. We have enough good players to rotate. Why doesn't he gives responsibilities to Yuvraj and take rest for series or two? Who is asking him not to take rest? He should take rest and also give rest to 2-3 players every match/series. If he says players are over playing, as a capton, he is on fault. He is not taking super starts like Ganguly,Rahul Dravid, and talking about overplaying:))
Vivek
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 4:28
For Sharad Pawar BCCI is a money making cow - so he is milking it. Single handedly he is destroying Indian cricket. He is not there for cricket or for its future - all he cares is how to make more money so that he can get his 'cut'. I shudder to think what would’ve happened had Laloo Yadav defeated Sharad Pawar. Unless, politicians and their cronies are kicked out of BCCI, the future of Indian Cricket is doomed. Only recourse now is – that "all" Indian players resign from BCCI and join with ICL and get BCCI de-registered and get ICL registered as the official Indian team.
omprakash yadav
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 6:21
I would like to say that what Mr MS Dhoni, Captain of our team said is very acurately said. Physical fitness aw well as rest are the most and vital issue for the team players so that they can do better for the Nation.
dinesh khatri
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 6:56
indian team is the idol of our country.as a saying a tired & hunger soilder never win the war.as the same thing if they feel tired.they should take leave.
chetan kumar bairwa
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 7:22
धोनी को धमकाना बीसीसीआई यह काम अनुचित है देखा जाऐ तो लगातार मैच खेलने खिलाङियो को आराम की जरूरत होती है ईसलिए धोनी को धमकाना अनुचित है गाव जेबाङिया - जिला टोक
Kumar
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 7:26
india cricket board is right.when they play in ICL or IPL why they did't feel tired bcz they get huge money .
shailendra sharma
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 8:28
MR. RAJEEV SHUKLA GIVEN A IMMATURE COMMENT. HE SHOULD RESPOND LIKE THIS "WE CAN UNDERSTAND THEIR CONCERN BUT SOME TIME THINGS ARE NOT IN OUR CONTROL, WE WILL TAKE CARE OF IT IN FUTURE". YOU CAN NOT REACT LIKE A CHILD. VERY GOOD QUOTE FOR MR. RAJEEV SHUKLA, "COMMON SENCE IS NOT SO COMMON".
GAJAN
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 8:41
its not proper way from bcci . our team has been bcci child
rameshwer
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 9:03
i think BCCi's member's are runing their monopoly. They think that we haver alot of money in this world so no body will oppos our work because we can satisfy them. but it is not so .
Rameshwar Sahu
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 9:15
I accept thought of dhoni about more(continue) cricket because it is not good for physical and mental health. thanks
Anil Kumar
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 9:26
jab kisi player ka selection nahi hota hai to wo bolta hai ki ek baar mauka de do. aur jab mauka milta hai to bolta hai ki jyada match khila rahe ho. jab ipl ke match roz hote thei to koi nahi kahta tha ki jyada cricket ho rahi hai. bcci ne yah option to de hi rakha hai ki jisko thakan ho rahi hai wo aram kar le to wo baher kyon nahi ho jaate.
mohit kumawat
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 9:38
DHONI IS RIGHT......!!
gurjeet singh raina
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 10:08
I will strongly oppose shukla for his comments. Wole of the administration of BCCI had made cricket as a hen which produces eggs of gold and they dont want an egg by day but they want whole eggs as soon as possible .They have no knowledge of cricket. We can see there is no charm in watching the game betn india-pak. coz they meet more often than they meet with their parents. One time we use to wait for india tours to diff. nations. but now a days when india loses one game with pak , noi one feels sorry coz we know they have other game with in a week. These bussinessmen administraters make money by local matches through poor indian people in the name of IPL. a simple person who earns simple life purchases a ticket of Rs. 500/ due to the cheap publicity through channels and media . This is all done by these big sharks . These shukalas, powar and Modis have nothing to do with cricket. they just making innocent people fool by their deeds . They dont know crickets A B C . though they are punishing cricket by making it bikini cricket for their short term goals. So it is obivious that a sports man of Dhonis calibre when steps againest their wishes, it pinches to them.They are just spoiling cricket and cricketers
GEORGE MANGHNANI
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 10:12
WELL I AM NOT AGREE WITH DHONI, THESE PLAYER HAVE LOT OF TIME AND ALWAYS READY TO PLAY WHEN THERE IS MONEY MATTER, BUT WHEN PLAYING FOR COUNTRY THEY MAKE LOT OF FUSS. WHY DHONI AND ALL OTHER PLAYERS DIDNT COMPLAIN WHEN PIL WAS GOING ON?? THEY GOT LOT OF MONEY NOW SO THEY WANNA HAVE SOME RELAX. SO WE MUST FIND THE OPTIONS FOR THEM.
rajusharma
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 10:17
dhoni ek sahi capten hai
Satbir
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 10:41
KAM SE KAM DO ak DIN KA REST HONa tha
praveen
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 10:56
I Thing Doni is wright, and every player support to him
ASHISH
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 11:09
While taking Such Big Amounts Why Dhoni and Company do not complain about Such Reasons of Getting tired.
Madan Singh
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 11:16
BCCI KA ES TRAH SE DHONI KO DAMKANA ACHA NAHI HAI.AGAR EK SHIPAI KO ARAMA NAHI MELEGA TO WAHA DUSAMan KE SHATH NAHI LAD SAKATA.
MAHMOOD KHAN
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 11:24
BCCI is going to mad. Without full confidance, stranth and consuntration no body can win the match. And regularly rest effect to these metters. So i want say only that DHONI IS RIGHT BCCI IS WRONG. Why BCCI doing like this. It is out of my thinking.
yagyadhar dwivedi
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 11:40
our indian captain dhoni is right
Padam Singh
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 11:49
Rajiv Shukla is right, Dhoni is cross his limit, when IPL is going on nobody complain of burn out , because IPL is money game,if Dhoni and others players dont want to play these series then they can take restand give chance to other players.
Romharshan
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 12:39
yes dhoni is wrong if he or his friend are THAK CHUKE hai then must to leave cricket there are lot of player in india still waiting for a chance in international cricket. we seen in IPL lot of inteligency in india there may we crete 100 team more good as our INDIAN DHONI team
Gajendra Singh
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 13:01
This is absuletly incurrect to warn india player by BCCI , the BCCI peaple does not know situation about the cricket ground , if they will on the field for 2 hrs for 2 days continuesly , after that they will realized ,
SHARMA
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 13:21
WE ARE NOT AGREE WITH DHONI. IF YOU TIRED AFTER PLAY TWO ONE DAY GAME.HOW DOHNI PLAY TEST MATCH.TEST MATCH ARE GOING 5 DAYS. why you have been playing 44 days contiune ipl then you have not tired. because he giving more money so he not telling anything
Sanjay Paswan
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 13:41
Abhi to Kaam chalela........... World Cup-2012 Laiyee aawe Dhoni Baiya BCCI Budhu hai Yahan par
Vivek Bais
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 13:55
बात ऐसी है की भारतीय क्रिकेट को बर्बाद कराने का फैसला बोर्ड ने ले लिया है. ऐसा ही होगा जब क्रिकेट की ABC न जानने वाले बोर्ड को चलाएंगे. जिन्हें ये मालूम ही नही की एक दिवसीय खेल में कितनी उर्जा (energy) लगती है. यह तो वे ही जान सकते हैं जिन्होंने कभी क्रिकेट खेला हो. अब बात बयान की है तो चाहे वो शुक्ला का हो या पवार का, ये सारे चोर-चोर मौसेरे भाई हैं. ये तो अटल सत्य है की ऐसे अवांछनीय व्यव्हार का परीणाम शायद आज भारतीय क्रिकेट को भोगना न पड़े किंतु ऐसे व्यव्हार के चलते भारतीय क्रिकेट का भविष्य ज्यादा उज्जवल नही है. इसके लिया सिर्फ़ बोर्ड जिम्मेदार है और बोर्ड से भी ज्यादा शरद पवार, क्योंकि ये सारी गन्दगी उन्होंने ही फैलाई है.
PANKAJ SETHI
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 13:56
अति क्रिकेट के इस विवाद में सहीं कौन है कप्तान धोनी या फिर बीसीसीआई? क्या अपने ही कप्तान को बीसीसीआई को इस तरह धमकाना उचित है, Captan Dhoni is right here. nobody can say any thing to him....
Kamal Manghnani
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 14:02
Abhi cricketers ki jaib bhari hui hai bhai..Thoda aaram karne do jab tak "out of form" ho jayenge phir rote phirenge BCCI ke daftar bharti kar lo sahib..... phir chutti bhi nahi magenge.
meena
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 15:09
BCCI ko istaraha dhamkane se uchit nahi hai agar koi baat dhoni ne kahi hai to Khiladiyo ki taraf se jo dikate ho rahi hogi tabhi to unone kaha hoga. agar kuch khel me dikate ya Thakan ho rahi hai to unka Khayal Bhi BCCI ko karana chahiye Akhir ve India ke liye Khel rahe hai dhoni ke sath baithaker unse unke Khiladiyo ke bare me janna aur uspar vichar karana jaruri hai
Md. Irfan
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 15:14
Absolutely, this is wrong statement threaten to Dhoni, Mr. Shukla is Comparing the IPL V/s 1 day, which is totally unacceptable. How can equal 20 over or 50 over matches . Definitely 50overs matches giving more tiredness, comparison 20. Secondly, every body is working/ playing for money, is he (Shukla) is not earning money from IPL or 50. Is he really playing for nation? So where is confusion. Rest is rest, which is right demand has to given to player.
arun
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 15:32
teek bola , Yes, its right. If any player feel tired , he can leave. Its opportunity for new players also
ARIF KHAN
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 15:33
IN INDIA CRICKET HAS BECOME BUSSINESS AND IN BUSSINESS YOU SHOULD WORK HARD AND HARDER ALL THE CRICKETER ARE PLAYING FOR NAME AND AFTER THAT ADD IF THIS IS CRICKET WHY WE SHOULD PLAY.
parveen
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 15:42
mere vichar se dhoni sahi bol raha hai.lekin me dhoni ko ak bath ye kah raha hu ki ganguly ko bahar bithana thik nhi hai.
neela chauahna
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 15:42
No this is not fair that everybody making statement to M.S.Dhoni, infact he is raight and BCCI only thinking about money and not for cricket player or thier health and even not for country, they want just more matches to earn more money, they become professionals only. they do not have any love towards the cricket as a game, it just mean to earn more money through it for them.
gurinder pal singh
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 16:04
Dhoni professional player hai. professional players ke muh se aisi baat achi nahi lgti ki weh thak rhe hai ya unko jyada khelne se thakan hoti hai. Cricket players ki ek mazdoor se bhot achi diet hoti hai, mazdoor bechara din bhar kam karta hai wo to nahi kehta ki me thak gaya. Baki bcci ko jo be decision lena chahiye wo khiladiyo ke saath mil bheth kr lena chahiye.
Tejinder Oshan
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 16:16
BCCI is very wronge ,Dhoni is right
durgesh mishra
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 17:08
sir the statement has given by rajeev shukla totaly like politician.such type statement would come down players comfidence of .every player can not be match winner . mr rajeev ji would have been think abut that it's no politics field.palyer represent the country and every palyer dose not play to yourself.so indian captan is right for good cricket becaz BCCI can earn to money from cricket but con't be cricket by money. and there r no authority for giving statement who doesn't know that how to play cricket.there much mor difirence between ground and outside of the ground
ravinder
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 17:27
i agree with doni. There is no doubt more and more cricket affects player's fitness. but now-a-day cricket is more popular. it make a lot of money also. every control board should increase their bench strength.
bimal
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 17:34
धोनी को धमकाना बीसीसीआई यह काम अनुचित है देखा जाऐ तो लगातार मैच खेलने खिलाङियो को आराम की जरूरत होती है ईसलिए धोनी को धमकाना अनुचित है गाव जेबाङिया - जिला टोक
Annilal Thakur
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 17:57
जॊ काम आज धॊनी जी नॆ किया है वह् पहलॆ सभी सीनियर खिलाडियॊ नॆ पहलॆ ही कह् दिया है तॊ हमारॆ क्रिकॆट बॊर्ड कॊ समझना चाहियॆ इनकी भावनाऒ कॊ. साथ् ही सामानता बनायॆ रखना चाहियॆ.क्यॊकि सभी दॆश कॆ लियॆ खॆलतॆ है.
V.Kumar
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 18:01
When thay all know that they are only playing for money & no for the country , then why to complain about "Burn Out". LAGE RAHO & CHAPTE JAO".that's it
vijay dhiman
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 18:50
thanks god dhoni is a cricket player not in the indian army other wise we can lose the war.he may think about army they get one time a chance in a year to meet there family,sill they never have so much money as dohni shame for dohni
shashank Gaurav
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 21:26
Rajiv Shukla comment is rediculas.He should stand in the scorching for only half an hour,he would understand the reaction of Team India captain.It would be better for Indian cricket if Mr shukla leave the BCCI and do journalism.
AZAD RATHORE
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 21:30
yes i am 100% with the dhoni and his team it is right that the calender of ICC is not good becouse it effect on the player fitness so the dhoni and kumble is right .
ROHIT
Tuesday, 1st Jul 2008, 23:25
YES DHONY KO AARAM KARNA CHAHIYA.
Pawan Pareek
Wednesday, 2nd Jul 2008, 8:27
In logo ko desh ke liye khelte hue rest ki zarurat hoti hai IPL jaise turnament ke liye .agar aap thake hai to rest karo .lekin aap chahte hai ki rest tabhi kare jab match na ho .baaki logo ko mouka do .dhoni apni manmani band karo aur time to time rest bhi lo khali dusro ko rest mat do khud bhi lo
brajesh chaturvedi
Friday, 4th Jul 2008, 16:50
i think dhoni is right & bcci is wrong